D'Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC

What Is the Difference Between a Birth Defect and a Birth Injury?

When your child faces medical issues at birth, the terms “birth defect” and “birth injury” may come up. It’s important to know these terms as they mean different things with different implications. A birth defect involves conditions developed in the womb because of genetic issues or environmental factors, and these defects are not caused by the birth process itself. On the other hand, a birth injury is an issue that arises during the birth process, possibly because of medical negligence. The distinction is significant, particularly when considering the potential for a medical malpractice case.

Introduction to Birth Defects

A birth defect is a health condition that a baby develops in the womb, often influenced by genetic makeup or environmental factors affecting the mother during pregnancy. These conditions, which include Down syndrome, congenital heart defects, and spina bifida, are formed because of a complex interplay of genetic abnormalities and external factors that the mother may encounter. It’s crucial for parents who are expecting to know that these defects arise from influences that typically occur long before labor begins and are not caused by the delivery process itself. Prenatal screening tests often help in detecting these defects, allowing parents and doctors to prepare for any special care the child might need after birth.

Causes of Birth Defects

Birth defects can stem from a variety of sources. Genetic factors play a substantial role, as some babies inherit abnormal genes or chromosomes that lead to these conditions. Environmental influences are also significant; for example, exposure to certain medications, chemicals, or infections during pregnancy can increase the risk of developing birth defects. Additionally, lifestyle factors such as smoking, alcohol use, or poor nutrition during pregnancy can contribute to the development of these conditions. It’s important for pregnant women to focus on their health and seek regular prenatal care to minimize these risks. Despite these precautions, not all birth defects can be prevented, and some occur without any clear cause.

Planning for a Child with Birth Defects

When a birth defect is identified, it’s vital for parents to receive proper guidance and support. Healthcare providers can offer detailed information about the specific condition, including its likely impact on the child’s life, potential treatments, and the care required. Early intervention services can be crucial in managing some congenital conditions, helping to improve the child’s development and quality of life. Parents might also consider connecting with support groups where they can meet other families facing similar challenges.

The Basics of Birth Injuries

A birth injury occurs during the labor and delivery process, setting it apart from a birth defect which is a condition that develops during pregnancy. These injuries are specific to the circumstances of birth and can result from a variety of factors during the delivery process. While some injuries may appear minor, others can have long-lasting or even permanent effects on the child’s health and development.

Injuries during birth can arise from physical trauma or medical oversight. For instance, if the baby is positioned awkwardly, like in a breech position where the feet come out first, it can complicate the delivery process. Similarly, if the labor is unusually long or rapid, it can increase the risk of injury. The misuse of medical tools like forceps or vacuum extractors can also lead to serious injuries. These tools, when used incorrectly, can exert excessive force on the baby’s head or limbs, potentially leading to nerve damage or fractures.

One of the more common types of birth injury is nerve damage. For example, Erb’s Palsy typically occurs when there’s an injury to the baby’s brachial plexus, the network of nerves near the neck that controls movement and sensation in the arms and hands. This can happen when shoulders are excessively pulled during a head-first delivery. It can also happen when there is pressure on the arms during a breech delivery.

Another serious condition resulting from birth injuries is cerebral palsy, which can occur because of oxygen deprivation. This might happen if the umbilical cord is pinched or twisted during delivery or if the delivery takes too long, preventing the baby from getting enough oxygen. Brain damage can lead to conditions such as cerebral palsy, which affects muscle control and coordination, or other cognitive impairments that can impact the child’s ability to learn and develop normally.

Fractures are another type of injury that can occur, particularly fractures of the clavicle or collarbone, which is the most common fracture during birth. This can happen during difficult deliveries or with the use of force during birth. Although many fractures heal, they can cause significant pain and discomfort to the newborn.

Identifying a Birth Injury

Recognizing a birth injury early can be crucial for the immediate and long-term health of your child. Symptoms of a birth injury may vary but typically include abnormal crying, difficulty feeding, weak reflexes, and in severe cases, seizures. These signs might suggest nerve damage, brain issues, or physical trauma. If you observe any of these symptoms in your newborn, it’s crucial to seek a medical review and talk with the experienced birth injury lawyers at D’Amore Personal Injury Law about a potential medical malpractice claim.

Medical Negligence

When a birth injury occurs, it often raises the question of whether medical negligence played a role. Understanding the legal implications of birth injuries is critical, as they differ significantly from those associated with birth defects. Unlike birth defects, birth injuries may be directly linked to the events and actions taken during labor and delivery. This distinction is important for legal purposes.

If a birth injury is suspected to have been caused by medical negligence—such as a failure to monitor the baby’s vital signs properly, misuse of birth-assisting tools, or inadequate response to signs of fetal distress—it may be possible to file a medical malpractice claim. In these cases, the law looks at whether the standard of care was breached by doctor or other professionals involved. A breach in the standard of care means that the medical treatment provided fell below the accepted standard among medical professionals in similar situations.

In a medical malpractice case, it also must be shown that this breach directly caused the injury, and as a result, the child and family suffered harm. This harm might include physical pain, emotional distress, a need for ongoing medical treatment, or loss of life quality. Compensation in a birth injury case may cover a range of needs including medical bills, costs for future care, special education needs, therapy services, and other expenses directly related to the injury.

Baltimore Maryland Birth Injury Lawyer

If you suspect that your child’s birth injury was the result of medical negligence, seeking legal advice is a crucial next step. A birth injury lawyer can provide you with guidance on how to proceed with a claim, help gather necessary medical records, and obtain expert opinions to support your case. To learn more about your rights and next steps, reach out to the experienced birth injury lawyers at D’Amore Personal Injury Law, LLC by calling (410) 324-2000 or contacting us online for a consultation.

FREE Case Consultation

Fill out the form below and we will contact you.

    Or, give us a call at

    410-324-2000